New guest tools ISO for Linux and FreeBSD. Can you help with the tests?

jmccoy555

@michael2z Yes, I get 7.20.0-7 on Linux (Debian 10).

stormi

@michael2z said in New guest tools ISO for Linux and FreeBSD. Can you help with the tests?:

@michael2z I neglected to mention that there's a newer guest utilities in the epel repository (xe-guest-utilities-latest-7.21.0-1.el8.x86_64).

Newer... Maybe. Ours is version 7.20.0 + various patches. 7.20.1 is not that different and may even lack support for Almalinux or Rocky Linux, depending on whether @cheese backported their support (that was added post 7.20.1) yet or not. Support can be considered full only once the installed tools are able to detect what distro they run on.

However, it's good to remind people that this package exists in EPEL and that you can use it instead of the guest tools ISO. Just don't forget to enable the xe-linux-distribution service after installation, as described in the docs: https://xcp-ng.org/docs/guests.html#centos-and-fedora

stormi

@gskger said in New guest tools ISO for Linux and FreeBSD. Can you help with the tests?:

1b-c, 2b-c, 3b-c installed with bash /mnt/Linux/install.sh, so CentOS 8 is now autodetected - nice

To be more precise, CentOS 8 > 8.2 is now detected. It worked until 8.2 included then the structure of the release file changed slightly and detection didn't work anymore. By the way I'm more and more convinced that we should use /etc/os-release rather than those fragile seds on release files. At least for distros recent enough.

See https://github.com/xenserver/xe-guest-utilities/issues/108

4b-c only installed with bash /mnt/Linux/install.sh -d centos -m 7

Thanks for testing that OS although you don't use it. Much appreciated. Can you share the contents of /etc/centos-release from that FreePBX 15 system? And the ouput of bash install.sh (without any extra options) and xe-linux-distribution from the testing guest tools? The installer script was supposed to detect the distro and offer the package installation right away.

4b-c showed Management Agent 7.20.0.7 but still no icon

The icon is added by Xen Orchestra so they probably don't know about FreePBX, simply. I suppose you can create an enhancement request for that. You can still check that correct information about the OS is displayed in the Advanced tab despite the absence of icon.

Apart from the change in Management Agent version, CentOS now being autodetected, and FreePBX not beeing autodetected I had no issues with the new guest tools.

About those versioning differences, our 7.20.0 is actually newer than Citrix' 8.1.50 (which is the version XCP-ng 8.2 has currently in its guest tools ISO). The reason for that is that one gets to choose the version number arbitrarily when building the tools. Citrix uses the version of Citrix Hypervisor (where 8.1.50 used to mean "the future CH 8.2" when the tools were built) and I chose to use the version of the tools themselves, from the tags in the upstream https://github.com/xenserver/xe-guest-utilities repository.

7.20.0-7 means "tools built from version 7.20.0 + XCP-ng patches, 7th build". Where the higher the build number, the more likely you are to have patches added by us, either backported from ustream or specific to XCP-ng.

stormi created this issue in xenserver/xe-guest-utilities

closed Use `/etc/os-release` for recent distros #108

gskger

@stormi Sure, no problem. But there is no /etc/centos-release, only a /etc/centos-release-upstream

[root@freepbx /]# ls /etc/*release* -la
-rw-r--r--. 1 root root  51 Sep  8  2020 /etc/centos-release-upstream
-rw-r--r--. 1 root root 423 Sep  8  2020 /etc/os-release
lrwxrwxrwx. 1 root root  15 May 14 12:26 /etc/redhat-release -> sangoma-release
-rw-r--r--. 1 root root  39 Sep  8  2020 /etc/sangoma-release
-rw-r--r--. 1 root root  39 Sep  8  2020 /etc/sangoma-release-upstream
lrwxrwxrwx. 1 root root  15 May 14 12:26 /etc/system-release -> sangoma-release
-rw-r--r--. 1 root root  34 Sep  8  2020 /etc/system-release-cpe

and cat /etc/centos-release-upstream returns

[root@freepbx /]# cat /etc/centos-release-upstream
Derived from Red Hat Enterprise Linux 7.8 (Source)

Running install.sh when the testing guest tool iso is mounted returns

[root@freepbx Linux]# bash /mnt/Linux/install.sh
Fatal Error: Failed to determine Linux distribution and version.

and xe-linux-distribution returns nothing

[root@freepbx Linux]# /mnt/Linux/xe-linux-distribution
[root@freepbx Linux]#

stormi

Ok, so depending on the version, they sometimes have /etc/centos-release and sometimes not... Can you add this line to xe-linux-distribution before the existing identify_sangoma call and test again? (you'll have to copy the Linux directory from the mounted ISO somewhere else then chmod the file to make it writable)

identify_sangoma /etc/sangoma-release && exit 0

gskger

@stormi Here we go

[root@freepbx Linux]# /tmp/Linux/xe-linux-distribution
os_distro="sangoma"
os_majorver="7"
os_minorver="8"
os_uname="3.10.0-1127.19.1.el7.x86_64"
os_name="Sangoma Linux release 7.8.2003 (Core) "

stormi

@gskger Thanks. I'll fix the script and submit a new RPM.

gskger

@stormi Great! I have snapshots at hand to test FreePBX again with the new testing guest tools iso. No need for testing the other distros again I assume?

stormi

@gskger Well, in theory I'm perfectly capable of breaking the other distros so better be defensive

stormi

xcp-ng-pv-tools-8.2.0-8.xcpng8.2 that should fix FreePBX detection for good (I still don't know why from two people with the exact same version of FreePBX, one has /etc/centos-release and one hasn't...) and hopefully not break anything for other distros... is available in the xcp-ng-testing repo.

gskger

@stormi Installed the new testing guest tools on my two playlab hosts (yum update xcp-ng-pv-tools --enablerepo=xcp-ng-testing) and re-run most of my earlier tests.

From fresh install to testing guest tools on FreePBX 15 (4a-c)

[root@freepbx ~]# bash /mnt/Linux/install.sh
Detected `Sangoma Linux release 7.8.2003 (Core) ' (sangoma version 7).

The following changes will be made to this Virtual Machine:
  * update arp_notify sysctl.
  * packages to be installed/upgraded:
    - xe-guest-utilities-7.20.0-8.x86_64.rpm
    - xe-guest-utilities-xenstore-7.20.0-8.x86_64.rpm

Continue? [y/n] y

Preparing...                          ################################# [100%]
Updating / installing...
   1:xe-guest-utilities-xenstore-7.20.################################# [ 50%]
   2:xe-guest-utilities-7.20.0-8      ################################# [100%]

You should now reboot this Virtual Machine.

From current guest tools to testing guest tools on FreePBX 15 (4b-c)

[root@freepbx ~]# bash /mnt/Linux/install.sh
Detected `Sangoma Linux release 7.8.2003 (Core) ' (sangoma version 7).

The following changes will be made to this Virtual Machine:
  * packages to be installed/upgraded:
    - xe-guest-utilities-7.20.0-8.x86_64.rpm
    - xe-guest-utilities-xenstore-7.20.0-8.x86_64.rpm

Continue? [y/n] y

Preparing...                          ################################# [100%]
Updating / installing...
   1:xe-guest-utilities-xenstore-7.20.################################# [ 33%]
   2:xe-guest-utilities-7.20.0-8      ################################# [ 67%]
Cleaning up / removing...
   3:xe-guest-utilities-7.20.0-1      ################################# [100%]

You should now reboot this Virtual Machine.

Managent agent now is 7.20.0-8, IP is correct and live migration as well as shutdown/reboot worked without an issue.

What I found strange is that for 4b-c (FreePBX) and 3b-c (Centos), I have to reboot the VM to make the new management agent show on the VMs general tab.
I can not remember that I had to do that in my last test and it is not necessary for 1b-c (Debian 10) or 2b-c (Ubuntu 20.04). No need to reboot 1a-c, 2a-c, 3a-c and 4a-c since the management agent is shown correctly right away.

stormi

Thanks @gskger. I think the fact that some b-c transitions require a service restart and others don't may be caused by differences in the post-update scripts that are run. Maybe the DEB packages we made restart the service while the RPM ones don't when the tools are updated.

This might already have been the case before, in Citrix tools, or maybe not. I don't think it's a big deal but it's interesting to note that difference. I'll try to have a look if time permits.

If curious, the package definitions are located at https://github.com/xcp-ng-rpms/xcp-ng-pv-tools/tree/master/SOURCES. debian-* files for debian, and xe-guest-utilities.spec. I think that not restarting the service automatically after an update is default behaviour in RPM world. I don't know about debian's position on this.

gskger

@stormi Perfect! Ok for me ! Any upcoming tests on the new guest tools? Otherwise I would try something else with my playlab, loosing the ability to conduct consistent tests .

stormi

@gskger no upcoming tests on the new guest tools. You can break your lab

gskger

@stormi Nice! Looking forward to when the new gest tools are available.

onyxfire

Just found this thread and tested the updates on the latest updated XCP-ng. They install fine on the Rocky Linux 8.4 GA release but there is a minor issue in the logs when you start the xe daemon:

Started LSB: @BRAND_GUEST@ daemon providing host integration services.

Looks like the branding isn't updated in your RPM.

onyxfire

Also testing Rocky Linux with test tools provided the following results:

Shutdown: OK
Startup: OK
Live Migration: OK

stormi

@onyxfire Thanks for the report. I'll fix it.

stormi

@onyxfire This is now fixed in the latest xcp-ng-pv-tools package in the testing repo. Can you test it?

onyxfire

@stormi Sorry for the delay in testing. This looks to be fixed now. Thanks!