XCP-ng 7.6 RC1 available

rizaemet 0

@olivierlambert I will try and will post result

olivierlambert

Thanks a lot! It's important to test between 2x 7.6 hosts, to be sure it's still an issue and not a problem from another version in the middle

conradical

@olivierlambert said in XCP-ng 7.6 RC1 available:

o test between 2x 7.6 hosts, to be sure it's still an issue and n

Mine is between multiple 7.6 hosts. PV tools, no PV tools, linux, windows. It all does it.

rizaemet 0

@conradical vm have any snapshot what you try to migrate? is this storage live migrate or vm live migrate?

conradical

@rizaemet-0
No snapshots. It happens on both storage migrate and love migrate.

olivierlambert

Any activity in the VM or it's idle?

Are they in the same pool?

conradical

@olivierlambert
Same Pool. It does not seem to matter if it is idle or not.

conradical

Interesting update: I installed the latest PV tools by enabling window update, this fixed 4 out of my 5 test VMs running windows. More testing is underway with linux PV and HVM.

olivierlambert

That's maybe the reason why I can't reproduce. It's like old tools will lead to migration problems but not more recent ones

conradical

@olivierlambert said in XCP-ng 7.6 RC1 available:

That's maybe the reason why I can't reproduce. It's like old tools will lead to migration problems but not more recent ones

HVM also have migration problems.

olivierlambert

I'm testing with PVHVM guests, I can't reproduce since I got latest tools installed

KFC-Netearth

I don't know if this helps but I have also been doing some test on 7.5 and it looks like VMs that are using a large percentage of their memory have problems migrating.
eg Centos 7 HVM with Atlassian bitbucket java process using about 80%
From top:

PID USER      PR  NI    VIRT    RES    SHR S  %CPU %MEM     TIME+ COMMAND 
 1874 atlbitb+  20   0 3695600   1.3g   6440 S   0.3 42.8   0:52.40 java                 
 1891 atlbitb+  20   0 4154320   1.1g   8124 S   1.3 36.5   6:40.68 java

Live migration stops at 99% and stays there till you cancel the migration and I have seen it go to 100% and the VM crash.
You then need to restart the toolstack on the receiving server or
/var/log/xcp-rrdd-plugins.log
fills up with these messages

 xcp-rrdd-squeezed: [ warn|xen1-3|0 ||rrdd-plugins] Couldn't find cached dynamic-max value for domain 66, using 0

Shut down the 2 java processes and it migrates OK.

I have also seen the same problem with migration of virtual disks between iSCSI SRs

borzel

@KFC-Netearth edited your post to see the top output better

olivierlambert

@KFC-Netearth That's really interesting. Do you have the latest tools version installed in your VM?

edit: I'll try to use 80%+ RAM on a test VM and see if it triggers the problem

KFC-Netearth

I have this version of the guest-tools on the VM
#rpm -aq|grep xen
xe-guest-utilities-xenstore-7.10.0-1.x86_64

olivierlambert

Seems to be latest tools.

Do you have anything during the failed migration in /var/log/xensource.log? Or /var/log/SMlog?

Aleksander

iSCSI possible problem:

I install XCP-NG 7.6-RC1 on 2 node testing pool and I get error when I try to attach iSCSI SR.

"The SR could not ne connected because the drive gfs2 was not recognized.
Check you settings and try again."

![0_1540743412810_XCP-NG_7.6-iSCSI error.jpg](Uploading 100%)

I create THICK volume:
![0_1540724487043_XCP-NG_7.6-iSCSI create.png](Uploading 0%)

With Citrix XEN 7.6 works fine on same QNAP.

Any idea what I do wrong or I encountered an error in XCP-NG 7.6.

borzel

@olivierlambert first testresults:

Situation

testpool at work with 3 nodes
XCP-ng 7.5 with latest regular updates
VM with debian 8.9, 2 vCPU, 2GB RAM, latest updates, xe-guest-utilities 7.4.0-1, x64, PVHVM

Test 1 - VM is idle

VM migrates just fine

Test 2 - VM stressed with `stress --cpu 1`

VM migration crashed with error, VM is stopped

Oct 28 16:17:52 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|32 ||xenops_server] TASK.signal 192582 = ["Failed",["Internal_error","End_of_file"]]
...
Oct 28 16:17:52 xen5 xapi: [debug|xen5|78975 INET :::80|Async.VM.pool_migrate R:e90b0ed1692e|xapi] xenops: will retry migration: caught Xenops_interface.Internal_error("End_of_file") from sync_with_task in attempt 1 of 3.
...
Oct 28 16:17:52 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [ info|xen5|28 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:e90b0ed1692e|xenops_server] Caught Xenops_interface.Does_not_exist(_) executing ["VM_migrate",["0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592",{},{},{},"http://xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx/services/xenops?session_id=OpaqueRef:89ad861c-f0fd-4d70-bb0d-4bf65741f13a"]]: triggering cleanup actions

(full log: https://schulzalex.de/nextcloud/index.php/s/pT456wEZkBoJrTw)

I had to execute xe-toolstack-restart on the whole pool to get migration working again.

Test3 - VM is idle

migrate just fine like in Test 1

Test4 - VM is executing `apt upgrade`

migrate stucks at ... VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100... until the upgrade inside the VM is finished and the VM is idle

Partial output of tail -f /var/log/xensource.log | grep -i migrate | grep -i progress

...
Oct 28 16:57:56 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:56 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:56 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:56 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:56 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:57 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:57 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:57 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:57 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:57 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:57 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:57 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:57 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:57 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:58 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:58 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:58 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:58 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:58 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:58 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:58 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:58 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:58 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:58 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:58 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:58 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:59 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:59 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:59 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:59 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:59 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:59 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:59 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:59 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:59 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:59 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:57:59 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:58:00 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:58:00 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:58:00 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:58:00 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:58:00 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:58:00 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
Oct 28 16:58:00 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|14 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:ccb8ffcf5ce5|xenops] VM = 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592; domid = 26; progress = 99 / 100
....

in the end the VM is migrated just fine

borzel

Test 5 - VM idle (with latest guest tools `xe-guest-utilities 7.10.0-1`)

migrated just fine

Test 6 - VM stressed with `stress --cpu 1` (with latest guest tools `xe-guest-utilities 7.10.0-1`)

same error as in Test 2
logfile from receiving side: https://schulzalex.de/nextcloud/index.php/s/XCPPzN5qcda59wL

borzel

Just spotted a difference in my logfiles
I migrated my test-VM in idle and in stressed state and recorded the logfiles on both the sender and the receiver host.

On the sender side there was a difference, see here:
https://schulzalex.de/nextcloud/index.php/s/aeoEFAD7TNWjfqk

Here the part that is different:

Oct 28 18:08:04 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [error|xen5|26 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:8d24f91b7cb1|emu-manager] Memory F 24499440 KiB S 0 KiB T 32766 MiB
Oct 28 18:08:04 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [ info|xen5|26 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:8d24f91b7cb1|xenops_server] Caught End_of_file executing ["VM_migrate",["0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592",{},{},{},"http://xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx/services/xenops?session_id=OpaqueRef:efd310cd-3d07-4d0b-92f5-531fe4a26614"]]: triggering cleanup actions
Oct 28 18:08:04 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|26 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:8d24f91b7cb1|xenops_server] Task 157 reference Async.VM.pool_migrate R:8d24f91b7cb1: ["VM_check_state","0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592"]
Oct 28 18:08:04 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [ warn|xen5|26 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:8d24f91b7cb1|xenops_server] VM 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592 has unexpectedly suspended
Oct 28 18:08:04 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|26 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:8d24f91b7cb1|xenops_server] VM.shutdown 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592
Oct 28 18:08:04 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|26 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:8d24f91b7cb1|xenops_server] Performing: ["VM_destroy_device_model","0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592"]
Oct 28 18:08:04 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|26 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:8d24f91b7cb1|xenops_server] VM.destroy_device_model 0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592
Oct 28 18:08:04 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|26 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:8d24f91b7cb1|xenops] qemu-dm: stopping qemu-dm with SIGTERM (domid = 31)
Oct 28 18:08:04 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [ info|xen5|26 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:8d24f91b7cb1|xenops] removing core files from /var/xen/qemu: ignoring exception (Unix.Unix_error "No such file or directory" rmdir /var/xen/qemu/21226)
Oct 28 18:08:04 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|26 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:8d24f91b7cb1|xenops_server] TASK.signal 157 (object deleted)
Oct 28 18:08:04 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|26 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:8d24f91b7cb1|xenops_server] Performing: ["Parallel","0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592","VBD.unplug vm=0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592",[["VBD_unplug",["0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592","xvda"],true],["VBD_unplug",["0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592","xvdd"],true]]]
Oct 28 18:08:04 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|26 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:8d24f91b7cb1|xenops_server] begin_Parallel:task=157.atoms=2.(VBD.unplug vm=0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592)
Oct 28 18:08:04 xen5 xenopsd-xc: [debug|xen5|26 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:8d24f91b7cb1|xenops_server] queue_atomics_and_wait: Parallel:task=157.atoms=2.(VBD.unplug vm=0c19e8aa-24d2-a6a4-5677-8ef4af6dd592): chunk of 2 atoms

There seems to be an issue in emu-manager if the VM is under load.

I want to test this again with XCP-ng 7.6, ~~but I don't have any other hardware laying around and I can't update the test pool at work for various non-technical reasons~~

Edit:

Just builded a testpool (XCP-ng 7.6) with same VM to test migration:

VM idle: no problems
VM stress --cpu 1 has the same behaviour

Oct 28 21:40:30 xen4 xenopsd-xc: [error|xen4|33 |Async.VM.pool_migrate R:27b04736b62f|emu-manager] Memory F 32865556 KiB S 0 KiB T 40958 MiB

VM is killed and off.

XCP-ng 7.6 RC1 available

Situation

Test 1 - VM is idle

Test 2 - VM stressed with stress --cpu 1

Test3 - VM is idle

Test4 - VM is executing apt upgrade

Test 5 - VM idle (with latest guest tools xe-guest-utilities 7.10.0-1)

Test 6 - VM stressed with stress --cpu 1 (with latest guest tools xe-guest-utilities 7.10.0-1)

Test 2 - VM stressed with `stress --cpu 1`

Test4 - VM is executing `apt upgrade`

Test 5 - VM idle (with latest guest tools `xe-guest-utilities 7.10.0-1`)

Test 6 - VM stressed with `stress --cpu 1` (with latest guest tools `xe-guest-utilities 7.10.0-1`)