Why changing objects in resource set wipe limits ???

Kptainflintt

Update : same thing when adding or changing "tags" field.

olivierlambert

Hi,

That would be helpful to know on which XO version you are running first.

Kptainflintt

@olivierlambert Hi,

I use xo from sources. Update two weeks ago.

From CHANGELOG :

@vates/types 1.10.0
@xen-orchestra/web-core 0.27.0
@xen-orchestra/rest-api 0.14.0
@xen-orchestra/web 0.25.0
xo-server 5.185.0

Thank you

olivierlambert

First, you need to update to the latest commit on Master, it's important to be sure in case something changed since then. Cf https://docs.xen-orchestra.com/community#report-a-bug

Kptainflintt

Indeed, I have 39 commits behind...

I can't do it now, as I have several users working on it.

I'll do this before next week, I come back if it's changing something.

olivierlambert

Keep us posted when you are on master, then we'll try to reproduce the issue when we can.

Kptainflintt

@olivierlambert

Hi,

Update was made now to last master branch (and big tanks to REST API doc integration by the way).

Working on a testing resource set.

Before :

xo-cli resourceSet.get id="h-PSp-FzCb0"
{
  id: 'h-PSp-FzCb0',
  ipPools: [],
  limits: {
    cpus: { total: 6, usage: 2 },
    disk: { total: 80530636800, usage: 34359738368 },
    disks: { usage: 2 },
    memory: { total: 12884901888, usage: 3221225472 },
    vms: { usage: 2 }
  },
  name: 'resource-test',
  objects: [
    '71359f87-2297-a2d9-1236-77ebfcbe71eb',
    '74f92165-9f40-a6b0-26e2-6377409d3911',
    '92751eb2-0007-fa22-9001-1b08db171145',
    'dd467579-027a-21a7-5c81-1a396312befb'
  ],
  shareByDefault: false,
  subjects: [ '6ddaf1a0-c440-4539-8634-c00a078aef78' ],
  tags: [ 'test' ]
}

Then, applying new object array :

xo-cli resourceSet.set id="h-PSp-FzCb0" objects=json:'["71359f87-2297-a2d9-1236-77ebfcbe71eb","74f92165-9f40-a6b0-26e2-6377409d3911","92751eb2-0007-fa22-9001-1b08db171145","dd467579-027a-21a7-5c81-1a396312befb","89ef16d0-9fc6-3bb0-8161-37dc69e64b3b","94f4a9be-5614-9a2b-a389-d0b2c8228b60"]'

After :

xo-cli resourceSet.get id="h-PSp-FzCb0"
{
  id: 'h-PSp-FzCb0',
  ipPools: [],
  limits: {
    cpus: { usage: 2 },
    disk: { usage: 34359738368 },
    disks: { usage: 2 },
    memory: { usage: 3221225472 },
    vms: { usage: 2 }
  },
  name: 'resource-test',
  objects: [
    '71359f87-2297-a2d9-1236-77ebfcbe71eb',
    '74f92165-9f40-a6b0-26e2-6377409d3911',
    '92751eb2-0007-fa22-9001-1b08db171145',
    'dd467579-027a-21a7-5c81-1a396312befb',
    '89ef16d0-9fc6-3bb0-8161-37dc69e64b3b',
    '94f4a9be-5614-9a2b-a389-d0b2c8228b60'
  ],
  shareByDefault: false,
  subjects: [ '6ddaf1a0-c440-4539-8634-c00a078aef78' ],
  tags: [ 'test' ]
}

Same result if I add/change "tags" field.

olivierlambert

@lsouai-vates we should try to reproduce and if we can, to fix it ASAP. Thanks!

lsouai-vates

@olivierlambert I am asking XO Team about this issue.

lsouai-vates

@Kptainflintt Hey! XO team dev is doing a fix on it: https://github.com/vatesfr/xen-orchestra/pull/8979

FYI @pdonias

pdonias opened this pull request in vatesfr/xen-orchestra

closed fix(xo-server/resource-sets): only edit limits if `limits` is passed #8979

Kptainflintt

@lsouai-vates

Nice ! Thank you!

olivierlambert

More than working on it, the patch is merged on master, so you can already use it now

Kptainflintt

@olivierlambert

Yes, I saw it !

Just finish update, testing tomorrow !

Thank to all the team

lsouai-vates

@Kptainflintt you are welcome We are always delighted when we can quickly unblock a user!
Have a good day and don't hesitate to come back if you have other issues in the future.