Error installing Ubuntu 24.04 on new xcp-ng host.
-
I can confirm this issue as well. Fresh vanilla install XCP-NG 8.3 on an HP server. Tried multiple builds of the Ubuntu 24 iso and multiple HP servers. All failed consistently. Installed patches on the host, rebooted and it worked. Went to install another VM today and having same issue again. I'm wondering if it was the patches or the reboot of the host that fixed it the last time. Worked fine with XenServer on same box, and I believe it worked fine every time with XCP-NG 8.2 on that same box. Its possible this just happens on XCP-NG 8.3
-
Thank you for also confirming issue. I think Vates is aware from comment in support ticket but still waiting to hear back. I did some extensive testing last night with 7 host consiting of 3 pools.
the one time last night i was succuess i want sure if it was because i rebooted everything or because i changed from LVM group formant to traditional format during the install but was not able to replicate again.
doing some further testing ubuntu server 25.04 will install successfully. Server 24.04.3 lts will not. Desktop 24.0.2 will install successfully.
After multiple test on work server and home lab. I did managed to install ubuntu 24.04.3 by telling the installer to not format the drive in lvm group. But after trying to replicate that i was never successful.
This was tested with between 7 different host. 3 home lab and 4 at work. For at work have paid support. All host fully updated XOA - 5.111.1 XO-CE commit 87471 all host on 8.3 with no available updates.
I also test other Ubuntu templates all end with the same results.
-
A acebmxer referenced this topic on
-
@olivierlambert I passed through this a lot of times yesterday. Same scenario with Ubuntu 24.04-3. I tried to download the ISO a few times, tried to create the VM with templates, with "other install media", etc, and failed all the times. Strange that I sucessfully created a VM with the same ISOs a few days ago... To solve my problem, I had an older ISO (Ubuntu 24.04-1) where I installed sucessfully (apt update && apt upgrade after) and "stonks"!
-
@dfrizon interesting i tried 24.04.2 iso and that failed but you state 24.04.1 worked?
Other thread believe this is a Ubuntu issue but as stated ISOs that have been download for some time worked in the past until recently.
-
@acebmxer Ubuntu 24.04.00 installed for me! I didn't run any updates during install. Perhaps didn't like something in the kernel that existed in 24.04.3. The 24.04 iso is available under ubuntu old releases.
-
just download Ubuntu server 24.04.01 and that installer did work. However there was a very long pause during the part where the installer would crash. Total install took close to like 10 min defiantly longer then previous installs of 24.04.3. Note my previous installs of 24.04.3 not having any issues. Only new installs failing to install.
-
Fixed issue. But now i have another issue, and that is with the fix.
Found this blog post - https://xcp-ng.org/blog/2025/10/30/xcp-ng-8-3-varstored-update-unbootable-vm-risk-and-remediation/
Running the two commands fixed my home lab no cert issues with vms
yum clean metadata --enablerepo=xcp-ng-lab
yum update varstored-1.2.0-3.3.xcpng8.3 varstored-tools-1.2.0-3.3.xcpng8.3 --enablerepo=xcp-ng-lab
My Pool #2 at work does not like the fix...
[06:24 localhost ~]# fix-efivars.py scan-pool
Scanning pool certs
Scanning all VMs
Found 3 affected variable(s) (0 oversized) in VM 600ab298-8ac3-af99-884b-590bc527584f - VM needs propagating with pool certs.
Found 2 affected variable(s) (0 oversized) in VM c81f1f1b-9f95-38ec-f96e-5ce8fea073e6 - VM needs propagating with pool certs.
Found 2 affected variable(s) (0 oversized) in VM 314958a7-c2ff-0079-4369-24423b4f8dd5 - VM needs propagating with pool certs.
Found 3 affected variable(s) (0 oversized) in VM bf1b61d5-14ca-9f0e-7040-24c177693cea - VM needs propagating with pool certs.
Found 3 affected variable(s) (0 oversized) in VM 3b6f1d1f-58a2-6639-216e-ee450a48614d - VM needs propagating with pool certs.
Found 3 affected variable(s) (0 oversized) in VM 9f36a8c5-c988-8546-b0f9-30ac9d0a5015 - VM needs propagating with pool certs.
Pool scanning done, found 6 affected VMs
[06:32 localhost ~]# fix-efivars.py check-vm 600ab298-8ac3-af99-884b-590bc527584f
INFO:root:Scanning VM 600ab298-8ac3-af99-884b-590bc527584f
INFO:root:Variable contains bogus data: d719b2cb-3d3a-4596-a3bc-dad00e67656f dbx
INFO:root:Variable contains bogus data: d719b2cb-3d3a-4596-a3bc-dad00e67656f db
INFO:root:Variable contains bogus data: 8be4df61-93ca-11d2-aa0d-00e098032b8c KEK
Found 3 affected variable(s) (0 oversized) in VM 600ab298-8ac3-af99-884b-590bc527584f - VM needs propagating with pool certs.
[06:33 localhost ~]# fix-efivars.py check-vm 600ab298-8ac3-af99-884b-590bc527584f --fix
INFO:root:Scanning VM 600ab298-8ac3-af99-884b-590bc527584f
Backing up existing variables to 600ab298-8ac3-af99-884b-590bc527584f.1761906821.efivars.b64
INFO:root:Variable contains bogus data: d719b2cb-3d3a-4596-a3bc-dad00e67656f dbx
INFO:root:Variable contains bogus data: d719b2cb-3d3a-4596-a3bc-dad00e67656f db
INFO:root:Variable contains bogus data: 8be4df61-93ca-11d2-aa0d-00e098032b8c KEK
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "/usr/sbin/fix-efivars.py", line 684, in <module>
main()
File "/usr/sbin/fix-efivars.py", line 677, in main
args.func(args)
File "/usr/sbin/fix-efivars.py", line 608, in scan_vm
dry_run=args.dry_run,
File "/usr/sbin/fix-efivars.py", line 446, in do_scan_vm
raise RuntimeError(f"{vm_type} {vm_uuid} is {power_state}, expected Halted; refusing to fix")
RuntimeError: VM 600ab298-8ac3-af99-884b-590bc527584f is Running, expected Halted; refusing to fix -
Helped if i read the error message....
raise RuntimeError(f"{vm_type} {vm_uuid} is {power_state}, expected Halted; refusing to fix")Shut down vm ran the fix again, and fix applied.
Edit - I did have to disable secure boot on windows vms for them to boot afterwards.
-
A acebmxer referenced this topic on
-
I just want to add that I am seeing the same issue with Ubuntu 24.04.3. Creating a VM does work, but it crashes immediately when trying to start it for setup.
I have not yet tried the approach of starting with 24.04(.00) and then upgrading to the lastest version due to lack of time.
We are still using XCP-NG 8.2.1 on the server in question. If an upgrade to 8.3 solves the issue, please let us know. Reading the thread, it appears to have the same problem, though.
Processor is an AMD Ryzen 9 3900X. We have not had any other issues with the system and it's been running for a few years.
-
@malemburg I had similar issues recently and in the past. The TL;DR version is to use an earlier version. I'm including the long version for those searching. They may be helpful for someone.
I'm rebuilding my netboot.xyz onsite to be more in line with upstream and avoid all the customization I built in a previous version. One issue I kept having was the installer would lock up randomly. CPU usage would be high like 80-90%. Unresponsive to input (if the lockup occurred on the user name screen). The issues didn't happen in 22.04, just 24.04. Sometimes it work and then it wouldn't. Google AI suggest it was a kernel issue. Some of the link suggestion didn't really support that claim, but I assumed that it was right. I even built a new XCP-NG 8.3 server and the issue still occurred. In the previous netboot install I used a earlier version of the 24.04 install. I only remember this after Google AI suggest a kernel issue.
So netboot (3.0.0) uses this as it version for PXE install: 24.04.3 and this ISO: ubuntu-24.04.3-live-server-amd64.iso. 24.04.3-717d3a1a/initrd & 24.04.3-717d3a1a/vmlinuz.
When I use this version: 24.04, ubuntu-24.04-live-server-amd64.iso, 24.04-dac09526/initrd & 24.04-dac09526/vmlinuz
After switching to this earlier version all my issues go away. Install is now 100% successful. My autoinstall file works great.
Doing an in place upgrade to 24.04.3 no issues. Works for bios and uefi. So I have a working PXE autoboot that install a new Ubuntu 24.04 with Rust Tools installed. Takes only about a minute to run.
