Feedback on immutability
-
@olivierlambert in general i believe creating it inside synology would be good for us but i can imagine an universal kind of solution would be the best.
-
It's not possible to have an universal solution, I mean we did a Linux solution, but as you can see each system is different (TrueNAS and such). So we should start with what people need/ask first
-
@olivierlambert agree on that, nas in general is a good solution for backup repos, we work with synology for years but i can imagine others have different solutions. We worked with nakivo prior to XOA and they supported several nas based versions, all app based, i can check with them on this if u like.
First goal for me would be to get it working on synology. -
I'm fine to target Synology first, so we need a dedicated resource to know how to build Syno app, because we have no idea.
-
@olivierlambert said in Feedback on immutability:
I'm fine to target Synology first, so we need a dedicated resource to know how to build Syno app, because we have no idea.
If you later target TrueNAS bear in mind that TrueNAS Enterprise has immutable Snapshots support.
Also TrueNAS Scale is based on Debian Linux and with the most recent update it's using Docker containers for its apps functionality.
-
@olivierlambert i will discuss with my 2 developers to see if this is something we can do internally or if we need to involve someone else. Who is doing this within vates? Can we discuss them directly?
-
That's still @florent and you know he's pretty busy ATM
However, you should have the immutability script available around to adapt it for Syno, it shouldn't be really hard and since it's fully self-contained, I don't see any risk to work on this Happy to review any contribution!edit: source code is here: https://github.com/vatesfr/xen-orchestra/tree/master/%40xen-orchestra/immutable-backups
-
@olivierlambert haha, let's not disturb @florent with this indeed, i will ask my dev to see what we can do with it and if we can adapt it to one of our syno boxes!
-
Also interested and willing to test on Synology support for this feature.
-
@olivierlambert we are starting to develop the synology version this week. I will ask my developer to contact you or support if he has any questions.
