Netbox Plugin: Error: ipaddr: the address has neither IPv6 nor IPv4 format

olivierlambert

@pdonias does it sound to be the problem?

pdonias

@olivierlambert Most likely, yes. But it shouldn't be an issue anymore after this change (XO 5.60) so I don't understand why the error is still happening.

@notscottsmith Do you see those space-delimited IPs in the UI too?

notscottsmith

@pdonias Yea, it shows up like this:

pdonias

@notscottsmith Ok, could you run this inside XO's directory with the VM's host and its password:

./packages/xen-api/dist/cli.js --au <HOST> root <HOST ROOT PASSWORD>

It should start a CLI. And then run this with the VM's UUID:

> find({ uuid: '<VM UUID>' }).$guest_metrics.networks

notscottsmith

@pdonias

{
  '2/ip': '10.44.254.253 10.44.254.254',
  '2/ipv4/0': '10.44.254.253 10.44.254.254',
  '1/ip': '172.16.130.25',
  '1/ipv4/0': '172.16.130.25',
  '0/ip': '10.1.254.238',
  '0/ipv4/0': '10.1.254.238'
}

pdonias

@notscottsmith So apparently, the old protocol also adds x/ipv4/x fields with space-delimited IPs. That's what causing the issue, so we'll have to handle them too. Thanks!

notscottsmith

@pdonias

So I've dug into the issue and written a few workarounds which will tide me over until a fix comes out - appreciate your work on this.

I've added a few features in, too. The plugin now:

Allows the choice of whether IPv4, IPv6 or Both types of IPs are synchronised
Allows you to enter in tags which will deem a VM to be "ignored" if they have one of these tags
Allows you to enter in text which if the name label contains it, it will also be ignored (we have a use case where we have several VMs which are decommissioned but are kept in XCP for various reasons as well as our backup process which maintains a series of VMs with the prefix XCP-BACKUP, which we don't want kept in Netbox)
Allows you to configure the ID of the configured VRF in Netbox (if needed) that the particular IP ranges relate to
Synchronises the platform that the VM is running
Brings across all the tags and puts them into Netbox (this is for our monitoring solution, OpenNMS, which uses Netbox to generate its requisitions and categories to automate the provisioning process)

I will submit these changes back into the Git repo tomorrow when I'm back in the office and you can have a look and see what you want to use.

theAeon

@notscottsmith @pdonias

any updates on this? Currently running into this error myself.

olivierlambert

Are you up to date? I think we fixed that already

theAeon

I think so? Unless my script isn't updating the plugins, which is totally possible.

edit: quick look at github says my plugins are fine

olivierlambert

Not the latest commit but I don't think it matters in your case. @pdonias any idea?

theAeon

Its the 5.66.1 release commit-so its damn close.

pdonias

Hi @theaeon, this should already be fixed, could you check the full log for that error in Settings > Logs? It should give you more details.

theAeon

Same as the OP.

netbox.synchronize
{
  "pools": [
    "582481e9-4e61-a060-6c09-530e35606504"
  ]
}
{
  "message": "ipaddr: the address has neither IPv6 nor IPv4 format",
  "name": "Error",
  "stack": "Error: ipaddr: the address has neither IPv6 nor IPv4 format
    at Object.parse (/opt/xo/xo-builds/xen-orchestra-202112260451/packages/xo-server-netbox/node_modules/ipaddr.js/lib/ipaddr.js:929:19)
    at Netbox.#synchronize (/opt/xo/xo-builds/xen-orchestra-202112260451/packages/xo-server-netbox/src/index.js:560:35)
    at Api.callApiMethod (file:///opt/xo/xo-builds/xen-orchestra-202112260451/packages/xo-server/src/xo-mixins/api.mjs:307:20)"
}

pdonias

Thanks @theaeon. Could you check if some of your VMs on that pool have invalid IP addresses? You can do that from the home page by filtering only the VMs on that pool (Pools selector at the top of the page) and expanding the details for all the VMs to show the IP addresses (hamburger button at the top right hand corner). Each IP address must be in its own blue rectangle and with the correct format for either IPv4 or IPv6. Let me know if this is too hard to check, we'll find another way.

theAeon

@pdonias One of my VMs isn't reporting an IP address. Do you think that could do it?

pdonias

@theaeon No, that's a normal case and it's handled properly. The issue would be if one of the IPs has 2 IPs in the same field separated by a white space like: "x.x.x.x y.y.y.y", or if the field is just empty or anything else that doesn't look like a proper IP address.

If you want to check the addresses more thoroughly, you can install xo-cli with npm i -g xo-cli, log into your XO with xo-cli --register <XO-Server URL> <username> <password> and then run xo-cli --list-objects --addresses type=VM \$pool=<pool ID>.

vilhelm

Sorry for bringing up such an old topic, but I have ran into the same issue (when syncing a certain pool to Netbox). I've used xo-cli --list-objects --addresses type=VM \$pool=<uuid of pool with problems> to get an idea of the data it's trying to import. There are no instances where there are two IP-addresses seperated by a space (like x.x.x.x y.y.y.ythe ) but there is one instance with an empty value.

  {
    "addresses": {
      "0/ipv4/0": "x.x.x.x",
      "1/ipv4/0": "y.y.y.y",
      "2/ipv4/0": ""
    }
  },

I'm running Xen Orchestra commit 667d0 (xo-server 5.96.0 and xo-web 5.97.2).

olivierlambert

Hi!

Thanks for the report Please update to the latest commit available, and confirm you still have the issue. I'm adding @pdonias in the loop

vilhelm

@olivierlambert Alright, I upgraded to Xen Orchestra commit 82452 but I am still experiencing the same issue.