Imported VM Starts but Does Not Initialize the Display

kagbasi-ngc

@manilx Yeah, not doing it in production, just in a test environment. Plus I only did it because I actually found a write-up by the Vates team on how to get it done, which confirmed to me that while they don't recommend it for production, they understand that it has some merit in a testing environment and want to see it working.

That said, I definitely hear your admonition and would never do it in a production setting.

stormi

I'm not spooked, I just think it's the relevant error message we need to understand :).

Since this is a test pool, could you make it use the debug version of OVMF?

ln -sf OVMF-debug.fd /usr/share/edk2/OVMF.fd

Then attempt to start the VM again, and get /var/log/daemon.log and /var/log/xensource.log once again.

kagbasi-ngc

@stormi Glad you're not spooked....

I'll enable the debug mode as you'd instructed and grab the logs for you shortly.

kagbasi-ngc

@stormi Hi there, as requested, here are the two logs:

I started the VM at timestamp Dec 13 13:54:59 and stopped it at Dec 13 13:55:59.

Now, is deleting the symbolic link created above all that is necessary to reverse the debug mode?

Mefosheez

@stormi @kagbasi-ngc I have this same error in a separate thread, however, there is no nesting involved. from my limited knowledge, it seems like xcp is not seeing the available memory resources during boot and fails. if I migrate a running VM to the same host that gives me this error, it will operate as expected. but, after reboot... failure to launch.

https://xcp-ng.org/forum/topic/10083/uefi-guests-not-loading-console?_=1734014269146

@olivierlambert Thanks for your help so far.

stormi

@kagbasi-ngc Looks like we missed something, as the log indicates it loaded OVMF-release.fd:

Dec 13 13:54:59 VMH01 xenguest-2-build[8345]: Loaded OVMF from /usr/share/edk2/OVMF-release.fd

We'll come back to you with a better test procedure.

For now I just have a quick and dirty one, consisting in overwriting the release file with the debug one:

cp /usr/share/edk2/OVMF-debug.fd /usr/share/edk2/OVMF-release.fd

You can revert this change with yum reinstall edk2.

kagbasi-ngc

@stormi Sorry for the delayed reply. I did as you requested, and below are the resulting log files. I started the VM at timestamp Dec 17 14:43:34 and stopped it about 2 minutes later.

If I can be of assistance, don't hesitate to ask please. Thank you.

stormi

@kagbasi-ngc @Mefosheez We're trying to find developer time to diagnose the cause, but it's not the best time of the year, so I can't promise anything on delays.

stormi

@kagbasi-ngc Does your VM have a vTPM? If so, could you try without?

kagbasi-ngc

@stormi No worries at all, I understand.

kagbasi-ngc

@stormi Yes it does. I just deleted the VTPM and tried starting it, but no success. Still the same issue - can't initialize the display.

I also disabled Secure Boot, and got the same results.

Mefosheez

@stormi thanks for the feedback. no rush here. just let me know if I can help.

Mefosheez

@stormi I wanted to follow up. I saw a good number of patches available today, first updates since the issues started for me. I processed them, but this issue still seems persist.

I know this thread is about nested virt, and i don't want to derail that. this is where i had posted about the issue prior. I believe they are going to be tided to the same root. any help would be appreciated.

https://xcp-ng.org/forum/topic/10083/uefi-guests-not-loading-console?_=1734014269146

stormi

@Mefosheez I forwarded internally. Feel free to ask again after a week if no answer comes.

Mefosheez

@stormi I marked it as a question about a week ago now. do you suggest making a new post as a question all together?

stormi

@Mefosheez Marking a new post as a question will not be necessary. @anthonyper is the one working on what we think is the issue (a regression on the EDK2 package). I haven't heard of a fix yet, but it's in progress.

Mefosheez

@stormi thank you for the update. and @anthonyper for taking a look.

anthonyper

Hi @kagbasi-ngc, I believe I've got a fix for your current issue, do you want to give it a try? @Mefosheez it's probably going to work for you as well.

I've prepared an update, could you install it?

# Download repo file for XCP-ng 8.3
wget https://koji.xcp-ng.org/repos/user/8/8.3/xcpng-users.repo -O /etc/yum.repos.d/xcpng-users.repo

# Update edk2
yum update --enablerepo=xcp-ng-aperard1 edk2

Alternatively, the RPM is there: https://koji.xcp-ng.org/repos/user/8/8.3/aperard1/x86_64/Packages/edk2-20220801-1.7.7.1.0.enomemfix.1.xcpng8.3.x86_64.rpm

And if you are curious about the change, it's explained in there https://github.com/xcp-ng-rpms/edk2/pull/4

Cheers,

tperard opened this pull request in xcp-ng-rpms/edk2

open OvmfPkg/XenPlatformPei: Allocate more memory when PEI FV is shadowed #4

Mefosheez

@anthonyper said in Imported VM Starts but Does Not Initialize the Display:

yum update --enablerepo=xcp-ng-aperard1 edk2

confirmed with ubunutu desktop 24.02 in uefi. i can confirm windows later today but this looks to be the fix. will this be folded into an upcoming release?

Andrew

@Mefosheez Does your host not have large HAP size?

Please show the output from xl dmesg | grep HAP on your XCP host.