Xen-Orchestra Terraform provider and Windows

julien-f

@olivierlambert https://github.com/vatesfr/xen-orchestra/blob/master/packages/xo-server/src/fatfs-buffer.mjs

I don't remember the details exactly, but it would probably be harder to do it with a partition table.

rochemike

Admittedly, I'm not proficient in this kind of programming, not at all. I tried reading through the code you linked to above and it makes no sense to me. Normally I would try to try fixing this myself, but I just don't have time to invest learning something that's this new to me.

However, I know in a bash script we simply partition the drive and it wouldn't change another thing about subsequent commands, because you're still writing to the drive in the same manner. How is that different in this code?

Your comments make me sad and afraid that you won't take up this challenge to support Windows VMs with cloud-init. I would ask that if you put this off into the future, that you update any blogs or documents to explicitly describe that Windows VMs are excluded from cloud-init compatibility for now, to save anyone else from spending as much time on this as I have.

On a personal note, the news that warm VM migrations from VMware will be built into the GUI for all versions of VMware is then a bittersweet story because it will give us what we need to support migration of our virtualization platforms from VMware. But lack of support for terraform / cloud-init for Windows would mean having to pivot to re-engineer our automation service.

Please advise what we can expect of this bug-squashing in terms of time.

Thanks for all you have done to create and continually improve this platform.

Mike

olivierlambert

We will discuss this internally ( @marcungeschikts can you add this to the backlog?) and we'll see if it's doable and at which level of difficulty

marcungeschikts

rochemike

@olivierlambert

I'm happy to help test if that kind of help is needed.

Mike

florent

@rochemike hi,

I did some test on a branch (adding a MBR at the beginning of the cloud init drive) : https://github.com/vatesfr/xen-orchestra/pull/6889 it should fix the windows problem. Can you test it ?

Regards

fbeauchamp opened this pull request in vatesfr/xen-orchestra

closed feat(xo-server): add MBR to cloud-init drive #6889

rochemike

@florent Great news! I'm eager to test, but tied up. I hope to get to it within the next 1-2 weeks.

Is there anything special I need to do from my end, or is the patch live?

Mike

florent

@rochemike for now the patch lives in a separate branch, it will reach master soon
it will on latest XOA by the end of the month

rochemike

@florent I confess I'm still new to things like "branches" I understand the concepts but am unsure how to go forward. Should I just wait until after the changes go live, or is there some way to test them before then?

florent

@rochemike I can help you for this

Do you use XO from the source or a XOA ?

rochemike

@florent XOA

florent

@rochemike great, that will be even easier

can you open a support ticket and open a support tunnel ? I will connect and patch your installation

rochemike

@florent ticket opened!

florent

@rochemike patch done this morning

florent

@rochemike hi mike did you have time to test ?

rochemike

@florent hello, I'm sorry for the delay.

Yes, and I'm getting errors.

right after "terraform apply" and answering "yes" to the prompt, I got this:

xenorchestra_vm.rbbmspcs2: Creating...
╷
│ Error: jsonrpc2: code 10 message: invalid parameters: {"errors":[{"instancePath":"/affinityHost","schemaPath":"#/properties/affinityHost/minLength","keyword":"minLength","params":{"limit":1},"message":"must NOT have fewer than 1 characters"},{"instancePath":"/VIFs/0/mac","schemaPath":"#/properties/VIFs/items/properties/mac/minLength","keyword":"minLength","params":{"limit":1},"message":"must NOT have fewer than 1 characters"}]}
│
│   with xenorchestra_vm.rbbmspcs2,
│   on vm.tf line 19, in resource "xenorchestra_vm" "rbbmspcs2":
│   19: resource "xenorchestra_vm" "rbbmspcs2" {
│
╵

So... I did some Googling and found that another person was experiencing a similar issue recently, so I added the following line to my tf file:

affinity_host = data.xenorchestra_pool.pool.master

Now, I'm getting this error - and I can't figure out a solution on my own. Any ideas? I haven't toyed with my TF files in months, ever since I reported this, and wasn't getting these errors back then.

xenorchestra_vm.rbbmspcs2: Creating...
╷
│ Error: jsonrpc2: code 10 message: invalid parameters: {"errors":[{"instancePath":"/VIFs/0/mac","schemaPath":"#/properties/VIFs/items/properties/mac/minLength","keyword":"minLength","params":{"limit":1},"message":"must NOT have fewer than 1 characters"}]}
│
│   with xenorchestra_vm.rbbmspcs2,
│   on vm-windows.tf line 19, in resource "xenorchestra_vm" "rbbmspcs2":
│   19: resource "xenorchestra_vm" "rbbmspcs2" {
│
╵

Here follows the simplified TF file I've been using, with the new "affinity_host" line:

data "xenorchestra_pool" "pool" {
  name_label = "b500-2555 Server Room"
}

data "xenorchestra_template" "vm_template" {
  name_label = "rbbmswsoe2019s_2023-02-28"
}

data "xenorchestra_sr" "sr" {
  name_label = "nfs-isilon-xcpng-b500-2555"
  pool_id = data.xenorchestra_pool.pool.id
}

data "xenorchestra_network" "network" {
  name_label = "VLAN113"
  pool_id = data.xenorchestra_pool.pool.id
}

resource "xenorchestra_vm" "rbbmspcs2" {
  memory_max = 8589934594
  cpus = 2
  name_label = "XO terraform tutorial"
  affinity_host = data.xenorchestra_pool.pool.master
  template = data.xenorchestra_template.vm_template.id

  network {
    network_id = data.xenorchestra_network.network.id
  }

  disk {
    sr_id = data.xenorchestra_sr.sr.id
    name_label = "VM boot drive"
    size = 50212254720
  }
}

gsrfan01

What is your version of XO? There was a breaking change a few months back that required a MAC address to be defined but was changed. It's fixed now so if you update to the latest version it would fix it.

Though I can't find it now, I remember having to roll back a version until it was fixed. Might be mixing this up with the affinity host actually...

In case this is useful, here is my ubuntu TF

data "xenorchestra_pool" "pool" {
    name_label = var.pool_name
}

data "xenorchestra_template" "template" {
    name_label = var.vmtemplate
}

data "xenorchestra_network" "net" {
  name_label = var.network
  pool_id = var.pool_uuid
}

resource "xenorchestra_cloud_config" "bar" {
  name = "cloud config name"
  # Template the cloudinit if needed
  template = templatefile("cloud_config.tftpl", {
    hostname = var.hostname
  })
}

resource "xenorchestra_cloud_config" "net" {
  name = "cloud network config name"
  # Template the cloudinit if needed
  template = templatefile("cloud_network_config.tftpl", {
  })
}


resource "xenorchestra_vm" "bar" {
    memory_max = var.ram
    cpus  = var.cpus
    cloud_config = xenorchestra_cloud_config.bar.template
    cloud_network_config = xenorchestra_cloud_config.net.template
    name_label = var.name_label
    name_description = var.name_description
    template = data.xenorchestra_template.template.id

    # Prefer to run the VM on the primary pool instance
    affinity_host = data.xenorchestra_pool.pool.master
    network {
      network_id = data.xenorchestra_network.net.id
    }

    disk {
      sr_id = var.disk_sr
      name_label = var.disk_name
      size = var.disk_size 
    }

    tags = [
      "Nightly Backup"
    ]

    wait_for_ip = true

    // Override the default create timeout from 5 mins to 20.
    timeouts {
      create = "20m"
    }
}

rochemike

@gsrfan01 I'm up-to-date as far as I can tell.

Current version: 5.84.0

I just want to build a VM to test another feature - what can I do to get past this message? I can't find a way to define VIFs in Terraform for XO.

gsrfan01

I'm wondering if it's because there is no pool UUID specified in your config.

Working bottom up we have your network which references the xenorchestra_network object

network {
    network_id = data.xenorchestra_network.network.id
}

Which is this, specifying the network name and references xenorchestra_pool for the pool information

data"xenorchestra_network""network" {
  name_label = "VLAN113"
  pool_id = data.xenorchestra_pool.pool.id
}

Which specifies the name of the pool.

data"xenorchestra_pool""pool" {
   name_label = "b500-2555 Server Room"
}

My config has the name of the network and the UUID of the pool that network resides on. I tried swapping it over to the pool name and my script errors out at applying the terraform configuration, swapping it over to the UUID of the pool worked though.

data "xenorchestra_network" "net" {

  name_label = var.network. 
  pool_id = var.pool_uuid

}

rochemike

@gsrfan01

I updated that stanza as follows

data "xenorchestra_network" "network" {
  name_label = "VLAN113"
  pool_id = var.pool_uuid
}

Now I can't get past "terraform plan" because "pool_uuid" hasn't been declared.

╷
│ Error: Reference to undeclared input variable
│
│   on vm.tf line 16, in data "xenorchestra_network" "network":
│   16:   pool_id = var.pool_uuid
│
│ An input variable with the name "pool_uuid" has not been declared. This variable can be declared with a variable "pool_uuid" {} block.
╵

No amount of googling is helping me to figure out how to declare "var.pool_uuid"