After installing updates: 0 bytes free, Control domain memory = 0B

olivierlambert

Can you md5sum xen-4.17.3-4.gz

From the mirror & RPM, I have f011721be0c7b57563e29ed282558da3

olivierlambert

Adding @yann in the loop in case I'm missing something obvious

yann

@Dataslak what does lsblk -o name,mountpoint,label,size,uuid show?

Dataslak

@olivierlambert

Dataslak

@yann
Hello Yann, thank you for pitching in.

yann

@Dataslak can you please request a commandline from GRUB (hit c on the boot menu), and issue the following commands:

echo $root
search --label --set root root-eqjpzg
echo $root

olivierlambert

Also a cat /proc/mdstat in the Dom0 would help.

Dataslak

@yann

Info: I am mirroring two M.2 SSDs ! Software RAID established by the installation routine of v8.3.
Could the mirror be broken and cause this somehow?

Dataslak

@olivierlambert said in After installing updates: 0 bytes free, Control domain memory = 0B:

Also a cat /proc/mdstat in the Dom0 would help.

Please forgive my ignorance: How do I execute this command in Dom0 ?

I've read https://wiki.xenproject.org/wiki/Dom0 and it helped a little. Do I run the command in the console within XOA?

yann

@Dataslak so it is choosing to "boot from the 1st disk of the raid1", we could try to tell him to boot from the 2nd one:

on the grub menu hit e to edit the boot commands
replace that search ... line with set root=hd1,gpt1
then hit Ctrl-x to boot

olivierlambert

@Dataslak Dom0 is "the host" (if you think it's the host it's not really but anyway), ie the machine you are connected to and showing results since the start

Dataslak

@yann
Wohoo!!
All VMs came up!
Host is not in maintenance mode.
Control domain memory = 12GiB
Stats are back
Etc....

As far as I can see (which is limited) everything looks good?

How can I see the status of the RAID1 and see if the mirror is intact ?

Dataslak

@olivierlambert
Thank you for explaining to me. I will look more into details when (if) I find time

Ah - I see you were ahead of me !

How can I interpret this? Raid1 OK? Synched? Ready to deal with a single drive failure?

How will XO inform me if one of the drives fails? Will I have to scour through logs, or will there be a clear visible notice in the interface?

olivierlambert

That's the problem. Your RAID1 lost the sync. And so it continued to boot on the disk out of sync, loading the old Xen from the boot while the rest (root partition) was up to date.

Dataslak

@olivierlambert
Since this happened on six servers simultaneously when applying updates through XO I guess we may have found an error ?

If so then all of this was not in vain, and I can be happy to have made a tiny tiny contribution to the development of 8.3 ?

Will the modification of the Grub boot loader be safe to apply to all remaining 5 servers? Or should I do some verification on each before applying it?

Is the modification of Grub what I will have to do if a drive fails? Change that one line from set root=hd1,gpt1 to set root=hd0,gpt1 or something?

olivierlambert

I don't know yet, but you lost one drive. Can you run xe host-call-plugin host-uuid=<uuid> plugin=raid.py fn=check_raid_pool? (replace with the UUID of the host)

edit: check that on all your other hosts

Dataslak

@olivierlambert

XCP-ng-002:
This runs 8.2.1 with only one drive. I was planning on upgrading it to 8.3 and insert another drive to obtain redundancy when time was available:

XCP-ng-003:

XCP-ng-004:

XCP-ng-005:

XCP-ng-006:

XCP-ng-008:
This server is clean installed after the problems

Can your trained eyes see anything I should be aware of?

olivierlambert

I can immediately see the hosts with the State: "clean, degraded" on XCP-ng 005. The rest is in the state "active", which is OK.

So you don't have a similar issue on your other hosts, it's only with this one, you have a dead disk (not syncing since a while). Try to check the dead disk and if you can, force a RAID1 sync on it.

Dataslak

@olivierlambert
XCP-ng-005 is the only 8.3 host I have restarted so far. All the hosts showing "3" in the triangle is asking for a reboot and claims hardware does not support virtualization.

Shall I try to reboot one of them and see if the RAID1 breaks like it did on XCP-ng-005?

If you plan on going home for the week-end soon then we can delay this until monday? I hope the power does not fail in the meantime (it very very rarely does; it is very reliable where I am).
I do not wish to keep you at work. But if you - like me - plan to remain at work then I am very happy to keep going.

Please forgive my rudeness:
THANK YOU for solving the problem so far! The 900+ USD I invested 3/4 year ago was money well spent. Not only is your product amazing. Your skill and availability is also great!

yann

@Dataslak if you only launched the upgrade and did not reboot yet, that alert is normal. Now if you did reboot them already, there is likely a problem.

One idea crossed my mind: when you upgraded to 8.3, in the list of products found on your disks, were you properly proposed to upgrade a RAID install, on all those hosts?