Xscontainer

olivierlambert

Can you check the presence of the key inside your VM?

kiu

Output to docker machine :

[XXXX@docker ~]$ cat .ssh/authorized_keys 
ssh-rsa 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 root@xcp-ng-XXX
[XXXX@docker ~]$

Output to XCP machine :

[07:53 xcp-ng-XXXX ~]# cat .ssh/known_hosts 
192.XXX.XXX.XXX ecdsa-sha2-nistp256 AAAAE2VjZHNhLXNoYTItbmlzdHAyNTYAAAAIbmlzdHAyNTYAAABBBNJxGOt3RvDXvelRUPTYyIHmykXhfRWSEN6PXSKYUVxct8qjENHqqqAEJOrl6E5cF9orOGQfbAPjSlLwNqGUGlo=
[07:55 xcp-ng-XXX ~]#

stormi

One or more added -v to ssh might tell why the keys are not accepted.

BenjiReis

@kiu I reproduced your issue.

The issue comes from a lib used by xscontainer as a SSH Client which use a deprecated algo ssh-rsa so all modern (>=8.7) OpenSSH reject the connexion.

BenjiReis

@BenjiReis following: I tested on a Centos7 VM with an older openssh and the prepare VM script was successful.

stormi

So, we found the reason: xscontainer in XCP-ng currently uses a rather old version of python2-paramiko, which seems to insist on using ssh-rsa algorithms, support for which was dropped in recent openssh releases.

That's why it works for some distros and not for others.

We'll see it to update the components. Meanwhile, it's possible to fix it by installing python2-pip from EPEL and then upgrading first to "cryptography < 2.6" and then to "paramiko < 3". However, doing this as root may overwrite the files from the RPMs so it's not really clean. I'd advise it only for testing.

kiu

@stormi OK, thanks. I will try your solution on a small lab.

kiu

@stormi I tried to do it but I don't think I succeeded. Could you send me a more specific doc of what you are doing?

thanks

stormi

UPDATE 2024-03-19: DON'T DO THIS. We won't support any XCP-ng hosts where system packages have been overriden with pip.

I think these are the steps that worked for me:

yum install xscontainer
yum install python2-pip --enablerepo=epel
pip2 install --upgrade "pip < 21"
pip2 install --upgrade "cryptography == 2.5"
pip2 install --upgrade "paramiko < 3"

As this is done outside a virtualenv (I've tried inside a virtualenv, but I think xscontainer runs stuff outside of it, so it didn't work), this will overwrite the contents of RPMs you installed, so, again, only for testing.

I also had to remove the former host key from the VM metadata:

 xe vm-param-remove uuid=... param-name=other-config param-key=xscontainer-sshhostkey

kiu

@stormi Thanks, I just tried that and it still doesn't work

stormi

Well, I tried it myself on a freshly installed pool, and this worked. Can you elaborate on what doesn't work?

kiu

@stormi I still have the same problem, the key does not want to install and asks me if I want to try again.

stormi

What's the exact error message?

kiu

@stormi

Would you like to push a pool-specific public SSH key into the ~/.ssh/authorized_keys file of the specified VM and therefore authorize hosts in the pool to interact with the containers inside the VM?
Answer y/n: 
y
Attempting to push the public xscontainer key to USER@IP.
ID@IP's password: 
Success.
Attempting to refresh the state of the VM
Failure diagnosis: Unable to find ncat inside the VM. Please install ncat. 
Do you wish to retry?
Answer y/n:

kiu

My server is up to date

stormi

It's not the same error. Your VM is missing a required package : ncat, as the error message says.

kiu

@stormi My bad. Ok I installed the nmap-ncat package under rockylinux and works perfectly now Thank you

Finallf

@olivierlambert @stormi
Is there any solution for this, I'm researching how to use xcp-ng + XO to build and manage docker.
When I read about Xscontainer I was excited because it seemed like the best option.
I have a small server and would like to know what would be a clean and transparent solution to achieve this.

I've read a lot and I'm still confused.

Below is everything I researched and read on the subject:
https://xcp-ng.org/forum/topic/3232/docker-on-xcp-ng?page=1
https://xcp-ng.org/blog/2021/09/14/runx-next-generation-secured-containers/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qOZk8xpIRpQ
http://oinformata.eti.br/wp/xcp-ng-8-0-debian10-docker/
https://doc.rmbinformatica.com.br/ajuda/redes-e-infraestrutura/xen-server/configurando-o-xenserver-para-monitoramento-de-containers-docker

codycrypto

I found another workaround (one-step solution) for the "Unable to verify key-based authentication error" without having to mess with any of the python packaging.

Adding

PubkeyAcceptedKeyTypes +ssh-rsa

To your /etc/ssh/sshd_config file will make the VM accept the older authentication

johnnyorange

@codycrypto this worked! thank you so much!