XCP-ng
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Groups
    • Register
    • Login
    • Profile
    • Following 0
    • Followers 1
    • Topics 3
    • Shares 0
    • Posts 91
    • Groups 0
    bvitnikB Offline
    1. Home
    2. bvitnik

    bvitnik

    @bvitnik

    42
    Reputation
    2.1k
    Profile views
    91
    Posts
    1
    Followers
    0
    Following
    Joined
    Last Online

    bvitnik Unfollow Follow
    • RE: Custom config / cloud-init

      @Pilow password: as a global option and passwd: or plain_text_passwd: under users: key are two different things. The first one sets the password for the default user, ubuntu on Ubuntu if I recall correctly, while the others set password for the user specified in the users: key.

      Read the docs people 😁

      posted in Management
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: Copy VM with new ID

      What he is talking about is Security Identifier (SID) and is specific to Windows. Each Windows machine must have a unique SID in an AD environment. Cloned machines will have identical SID which is bad.

      The solution to this problem is sysprep, a Windows tool that will reset SID and other parameters so that each Windows installation is uniquely identifiable. This is something done inside a machine, of course, and is not something that can be done on HV level. VMware, and Hyper-V as seen here, have integrated support for invoking sysprep (or equivalent) during the machine cloning process. This is achieved by sending a signal to the management agent inside a machine (e.g. VMware Guest Tools).

      As far as I know, XenServer/XCP-ng management agent is rudimentary and does not have this functionality. In world of XenServer/XCP-ng, machine has to be syspreped manually before it is cloned.

      posted in Management
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: Custom config / cloud-init

      @acebmxer Great. These are some YAML basics. You should read more about it ☺ . Following AI instructions without understanding is not going to take you far.

      posted in Management
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: Ansible with Xen Orchestra

      @john-c

      I feel your pain, however, the main difference between VMware support in Ansible and XenServer/XCP-ng is that VMware has a whole working group with a dozen of regular members and contributors:

      https://github.com/ansible/community/wiki/VMware

      Major contributors are all Red Hat or VMware employees i.e. people paid to do it. There is no such thing for XenServer/XCP-ng. Citrix never showed any interest in supporting Ansible. Netscaler is the only Citrix product that has a decent Ansible support.

      To help you better understand how Ansible as a project works, here are some points from my personal adventure:

      • To be able to contribute new modules to Ansible or any of the official collections, you need to implement extensive unit and integration tests. I understand the requirement. Ansible/Red Hat wants to maintain a high level of quality and to easily (and in automated way) detect any regressions. That's all good but implementing tests is harder and more work than implementing modules themselves. What's very very helpful in case of VMware is that there is a whole simulator called govcsim developed by VMware. You can test your modules against the simulator with ease and automate all the tests with little effort. To my knowledge, there is no simulator available for XenAPI. If such simulator does exist, it is most likely kept in secret by Citrix. If Citrix was ever to release this simulator, that would be a HUGE step forward.
      • If you want to contribute new modules to Ansible or any of the official collections, someone has to review your code. Not many people are willing to do so and have the power to include your code to Ansible. As a matter of fact, finding reviewers and begging them for help is the hardest thing of all. I had some tremendous luck to acquire the interest of Abhijeet Kasurde, one of the top Ansible guys, to review my code and to eventually include xenserver_guest_* modules into Ansible. The guy handles VMware in Ansible... surprise! 😀 My xenserver_guest module was included without any unit or integration tests but for other modules I had to implement them. Luckily, they were simple and I had a luck to find a reviewer for tests also. When I wanted to upgrade xenserver_guest module with new functionality, they required unit and integration tests. I eventually implemented tests for xenserver_guest module but it was a huge undertaking and the amount of code involved easily dwarfed the module itself. I basically ended up implementing a barebone XenAPI simulator. This is where I hit a road block. No one, even the people that initially supported me, wanted to review this monstrosity of test+simulator. It was never included in Ansible.
      • If you don't want to rely on external reviewers then you have to form a team, or if possible, a work group. That way you can review each others code and include it in Ansible without external support. Everything is pretty much handled by bots. If you gain a high enough status in Ansible project, you could get permissions to merge the code yourself without relying on anyone, not even bots. Should I mention that I failed to ever find any good Python programmer that is into Ansible and interested enough to form a team with me?
      • You can skip all this struggle if you just maintain you own collection of modules but then you cannot rely on existing Ansible tooling that will do all the testing, linting, sanity checks, spell checks and such. You are on your own.

      After a lot of struggle I eventually lost any interest as I was wasting a lot of time and life had to go on. Not much people showed interest in xenserver_guest_* Ansible modules either. My employer also ditched XenServer/XCP-ng in favor of VMware a few years back. Even with all the Broadcom/VMware situation, we got a super good deal with Broadcom because of our deployment size and commitment so we are sticking with VMWare.

      All in all, if Ansible support for XenServer/XCP-ng and Xen Orchestra on par with VMware support is ever to see the light of day, these prerequisites are required:

      • Publicly available XenAPI simulator is a must
      • A working group of at least three people with knowledge in Python, Ansible and XenAPI committed to the cause
      • Possibly corporate and financial backing by Citrix, Vates? or some other third party

      Having any official Ansible support for XenServer/XCP-ng was (and is) a miracle to this day. A miracle I was blessed with and a huge learning experience for me.

      Sorry for the long post. It is not my intention to discourage people but I think everyone should understand why XenServer/XCP-ng does not enjoy better Ansible support. There is much much more to it than just having a willingness to do anything.

      posted in Infrastructure as Code
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: XCP-ng 8.0.0 Release Candidate

      Just to confirm. After copying new install.img to my PXE environment, unattended installation went smoothly with my answer file.

      posted in News
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: New project - XenAdminQt - a cross-platform GNU/Linux, macOS, Windows native thick client

      @benapetr This looks phenomenal. Will have to give it a try.

      This is a nice coincidence. Just the other day one of my younger colleagues boasted about making XCP-ng Center work under Wine... everything just works™. It would save a number of folks having to have a Windows VM on stand by just for the XCP-ng Center. Oh boy, how he was disappointed when I showed him everything that does not work 😁 ... but with this, there is still hope.

      posted in News
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: Deploy VMs using Ansible

      A milestone has been achieved 😱 . All of my modules have been merged upstream. I've updated the first post with new info.

      That will most probably be all for Ansible 2.8. I'm keeping some improvements and possibly more modules for Ansible 2.9. Currently, I'm thinking about what other modules could be useful so I could implement them. Any suggestion or wish would be much appreciated.

      posted in Development
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: Booting to Dracut (I trusted ChatGPT)

      @nuentes Oh no, no. Your system is not destroyed beyond repair. It can be repaired. It's just that it is almost impossible or too much of a hustle for anyone to try to help you over forum. Someone has to sit in front of your machine to do it.

      My only guess is that ChatGPT instructed you to make changes based on a CentOS system but XCP-ng and Xen virtualization in general is much different than regular CentOS. It has two stage boot process. First the Xen kernel boots and then a special virtual machine called Dom0 is booted. What you are accessing and reconfiguring is in fact this VM, not the underlying "system". So it's like a two layer system and some configuration must be done on Xen layer, some on Dom0 layer. I'm unfortunately unfamiliar with exact specifics on kernel and initrd image generation for this case so I can't spot where thing have gone wrong.

      In short terms. Instead of going back and forth and trying a lot of different things, it's more time saving and simpler to reinstall the system and restore metadata if you already have a backup.

      posted in XCP-ng
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: Guest running kernel 6.8 hangs after a while

      Has anyone been able to install Ubuntu 24.04 in VM from current official ISO? It seems that official ISOs (i.e. installer) still use unpatched kernel 6.8.0-22. Are there any newer ISO builds that I'm not aware of?

      EDIT:
      Sorry. False alarm. I screwed up my PXE settings. There was some leftover kernel and initrd images from beta versions of ISO. Kernel and initrd from latest ISOs work properly.

      posted in XCP-ng
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: Custom config / cloud-init

      @acebmxer Did you do:

      cloud-init clean --logs --seed
      

      before converting the VM to template?

      Also, network configuration is not part of the cloud-config (aka user data). In XO, there is a separate field called "Network config" where it should be specified. See examples at the end of the guide I pasted earlier. network: key should also be removed (commented in the examples).

      posted in Management
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: New project - XenAdminQt - a cross-platform GNU/Linux, macOS, Windows native thick client

      @benapetr Yep. My message is based on 2 days old commit. I've compiled the latest one and the list at the bottom is collapsable now. I don't see the down arrow on "Organization" and "Saved searches" icons though like in your screenshot:

      image.jpeg

      The next few things:

      • Saved searches is empty. By default, there are some useful built in saved searches.

      image.jpeg

      • When you select a pool, on the info panel to the right the "Default SR" shows an OpaqRef instead of SR name. Reference should be dereferenced.
      • A little bit nitpicking. Vertical spacing of the elements in the tree view is a little bit higher compared to xenadmin. It could be made smaller to pack more stuff on the screen but this is just visual preference.
      posted in News
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: New project - XenAdminQt - a cross-platform GNU/Linux, macOS, Windows native thick client

      @benapetr Here are some more bugs:

      • Templates are still not sorted correctly in the tree view. User templates (blue) should go first then built in ones (yellow). Each group should be sorted alpabetically (see the screenshot).
      • Icons are back for categories (under the tree view) but elements should be left aligned. They look ugly when centered (screenshot).
      • Categories are still not collapsable to a single icon like shown in previous screenshots.
      • With the addition of horizontal scrollbar, there seems to be an ugly regression in tree view itself. The tree view is refreshed each 30 sec but while doing so, the tree is collapsed and then expanded. It's a little bit hard to explain but the tree just "jumps" in front of the eyes. This is particularly annoying while doing something in the tree view.
      • The New VM dialog, template selection section, now seems to be functionally identical, not visually though.

      image.jpeg

      posted in News
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: New project - XenAdminQt - a cross-platform GNU/Linux, macOS, Windows native thick client

      @benapetr The thing @clip is talking about is when the bottom panel (under the tree) is resized vertically, or better said squished vertically, the elements of the list (Infrastructure, Objects...) get replaced by a single horizontal icon at the bottom, one by one:

      image.jpeg

      and even more

      image.jpeg

      posted in News
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: New project - XenAdminQt - a cross-platform GNU/Linux, macOS, Windows native thick client

      @benapetr Do you have some way or script to quickly iterate build->test workflow locally? That is without building a package, then installing on a system then testing. I'm running Debian based system.

      posted in News
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: New project - XenAdminQt - a cross-platform GNU/Linux, macOS, Windows native thick client

      @benapetr Great. Thanks!

      posted in News
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: New project - XenAdminQt - a cross-platform GNU/Linux, macOS, Windows native thick client

      @benapetr One of the things I've noticed during my initial testing is that there is a problem in how VM templates are handled compared to xenadmin. Here are my observations:

      • Built in templates are shown with yellow icons in the tree view (if enabled with View -> Templates) and this seems to work as expected.
      • User made templates are also shown with yellow icon in the tree view which is wrong. They should be shown with blue icon and sorted before any built in templates.
      • VM snapshots are shown as VM templates with blue icons in the tree view. They should not be shown at all in the tree view. Additionally, they are shown under a host instead of a pool compared to other templates.
      • New VM dialog does not show VM template icons at all so it is hard to distinguish if they are builtin or user created or snapshots (which can be used as VM templates too). Snapshots are not shown in the list at all.
      • New VM dialog also does not sort the templates by name nor group per type (builtin, user, snapshot) so it is hard to find what you need.

      If I get some extra time, I will add some screenshots for comparison.

      posted in News
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: cloud-init Cloud Config use of {name}

      @bug-meister Yeah, I would say the "mechanism" is deprecated too. Getting this mechanism to work, either by using ansible-pull or by some clever scripting during the first boot, requires Ansible to be preinstalled on your VM templates. That just makes your VMs messy and bloated with additional stuff you only use once. Also, managing Ansible versions becomes more complex. If Ansible is installed from distro repositories, you will have all different versions of Ansible across different distros. If you use pip to install Ansible, it can mess up your system if Ansible dependencies are installed on a system level. You can use Python virtual environments to prevent that but requires additional managing.

      It's much better and much more practical to have Ansible installed and used from a single place - Control Node. That way you have one place, one OS, one Ansible version to think about. You already have a machine you are accessing your VMs from? Use that as a control node... unless it is Windows?

      posted in Infrastructure as Code
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: cloud-init Cloud Config use of {name}

      @bug-meister My opinion is that cloud-init should be used only for the most basic stuff like initial network configuration, initial user creation and credentials injection. As soon as you gain the ability to access the VM, some more robust configuration management solution like Ansible should take over.

      ansible-pull mechanism is in today's day and age effectively deprecated. Just run Ansible after the VM has been provisioned to apply the configuration. If you need to call Ansible as soon as VM is provisioned without any manual invocation, you can have Terraform provision the VM and call Ansible right after that. You can even use pure Ansible for both - provisioning, with my community.general.xenserver_guest module, and configuration. You just invoke Ansible once and everything will be done in one go. The only drawback is that my module does not support cloud-init so you would need some trickery to do the stuff.

      posted in Infrastructure as Code
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: cloud-init Cloud Config use of {name}

      @bug-meister Ah. That's cloud-init's support for templating user-data. The issue is that with these templates you only have access to the info available inside the VM itself. No outside data can be used for templating unless it is somehow passed to the VM (inject a file, set xenstore values...)

      posted in Infrastructure as Code
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik
    • RE: cloud-init Cloud Config use of {name}

      @bug-meister Nope. This is not Jinja nor any other kind of templating engine. This is a simple search-and-replace kind of implementation and is limited to name and %, the later being VM index. From the docs:

      Xen Orchestra offers the ability to insert variables such as the virtual machine name {name} or a virtual machine index %. However, the expressive power is limited to the graphical interface. For instance, it is not possible to build a series of virtual machines with complex values or from external data.

      Reference:

      • https://docs.xcp-ng.org/guides/create-use-custom-xcpng-ubuntu-templates/

      In other words, there is no advanced templating of cloud-init configuration but you could probably template it outside XenOrchestra and apply it via Terraform:

      • https://registry.terraform.io/providers/vatesfr/xenorchestra/latest/docs/resources/vm
      posted in Infrastructure as Code
      bvitnikB
      bvitnik