Pretty sure I figured this out. I went to update the Xenserver tools, and the updater said the installer was busy. That meant the machine was in a "dirty condition" and couldn't work right. The dirty condition was the newest Xenserver tools needing a couple more reboots to get fully insatalled.
testing now and will have to wait on the DC until the network use get lighter this afternoon.
Running the second VM right now, but pretty sure it will now pass the health check. I'll update after I check the DC in a few hours.